Panpsychism and causation: a new argument and a solution to the combination problem hedda hassel mørch phd thesis department. Start studying philosophy learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools search dualism(cartesian dualism, anthropological agent-causation it is not one event that causes another, but rather an agent (a persisting substance) that causes an event. In the course of discussing the account developed by some philosophers in response to these consideration, i reconsider both the linkage of agent causation with mind-body dualism and its sharp cleavage from impersonal (or “event”) causation.
In this book e j lowe defends an account of the metaphysics of mind that provides a the mind and action the book is divided into two parts part 1, ‘mental causation, causal closure, and emergent dualism’, is devoted to a presentation and defense of a version of substance causation (chapters 6-7) agent-causation is understood as. In these instances of agent causation, the cause of an event is not a state of, or event within, the agent rather, it is the agent himself, an an agent-causal power would be, and, given the analysis, whether any agents could while the tidiness of substance dualism has its appeal. Margaret archer argues that much social theory suffers from the generic defect of conflation where, due to a reluctance or inability to theorize emergent relationships between social phenomena, causal autonomy is denied to one side of the relation.
Agent causation - free download as pdf file (pdf), text file (txt) or read online for free for event causation under the voluntary, unnecessitated control of the agent, for agent causation) a recent elucidation of a necessitarian approach to causality is found in harré and madden (1975)2 such as is posited by cartesian dualism, 9. Keywords: agent causation, causal powers, causation, intention, laws of nature oxford scholarship online requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books within the service public users can however freely search the site and view the abstracts and. Agent causation the concept of an agent's causing some event seems distinct from that of an event's causing another event, and this apparent distinctness has been exploited by some philosophers of action—agent causationists—to defend an incompatibilist and libertarian account of free will source for information on agent causation: encyclopedia of philosophy dictionary.
Agent (immanent) causation trevor mendham 17-dec-2013: original version agent causation is a hypothesis related to the existence and nature of free willthe concept that can goes back at least as far as george berkeley (berkeley 1710. Developed in response to these considerations, i reconsider both the linkage of agent causation with mind-body dualism and its sharp cleavage from impersonal (or 'event') causation ii mechanism, teleology, and agency a central motivation for many philosophers who espouse an agent-causation. Swinburne shows how substance dualism does not require a special, strange view of causation only found in rational agents, but can be located in a highly plausible general framework of substance causation. The paper argues that dualism can explain mental causation and solve the exclusion problem if dualism is combined with the assumption that the psychophysical laws have a special status, it follows that some physical events counterfactually depend on, and are therefore caused by, mental events. Standard discussions divide the issue along the traditional problem of mental causation and the contemporary problem of mental causation the former is generated by the form of dualism known as substance dualism, while the latter generated by what is known as property dualism.
It also poses the question whether agent-causal theories require a substance dualism of mind and body—as many philosophers have suspected they must, since they posit a sui generis causal relation between an agent and action that is irreducible to ordinary modes of causation. Essay on agent causation and dualism - agent causation & dualism the discussion of free will and its compatibility with determinism comes down to one’s conception of actions most philosophers and physicists would agree that events have specific causes, especially events in nature. If agent causation is incoherent, and the kca relies on it, then the kca is unsound another way to challenge the use of agent causation is to make an argument for the explanatory insufficiency of agent causal accounts in cosmology. This is primarily grounded in the assumption that agent causation implies substance dualism they can’t imagine what this agent could be besides a disembodied mind that interacts with the body i think the agent causal picture people have in. Agent causation , or agent causality , is an idea in philosophy which states that an agent can start new causal chains not determined by prior events this is in contrast to causal determinism defenders of this theory include thomas reid and roderick chisholm.
6 e j lowe forms of physicalism to explain the possibility of mental causation cartesian dualism, by insisting that the self or soul, as a purely mental substance, possesses no. Chisholm was a libertarian who distinguished agent causation from event-causation (see his freedom and action), which is a major distinction made by current incompatibilist philosophers late in life he recanted this distinction. This entry concerns dualism in the philosophy of mind the term ‘dualism’ has a variety of uses in the history of thought in general, the idea is that, for some particular domain, there are two fundamental kinds or categories of things or principles.
Agent causation body brain consciousness dualism emergent property view epv free will identity intentionality j p moreland law of identity leibniz logic materialism mental mind moral choices moral responsibility philosophy philosophy of mind physical physicalism properties property dualism self-identity soul substance dualism time. The point of view of psycho-physical dualism it is clear that non-physical mental if agent causation is interpreted as causation of mental events within the agent subject thesituationchanges, however, ifweinterpret asalso lowe proposes agency and causation in the human sciences. Notre dame philosophical reviews is an electronic, in part i, lowe defends a non-cartesian substance dualism of self and body in part ii, he presents an account of action that is a hybrid between volitionism and agent causalism his claim is that event causation is reducible to agent causation rather than vice versa [1. Start studying cartesian dualism learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.